D&C 117: Nine Verses to Two Men, Then Three Separate Charges

By David Whitaker

The way D&C 117 usually gets summarized, and the way my own reading checklist words it, is that the Lord rebukes some Kirtland men for covetousness over small things. I don't buy that as a summary of the chapter. It fits verses 4 and 8 well and has very little to say about the other fourteen, and the other fourteen are where the instructions are.

The chapter is sixteen verses long and it's built in layers. Verses 1 through 9 are one set of instructions to William Marks and Newel K. Whitney together: settle up, leave, don't tarry, repent of covetous desires, turn the properties out for debts, come up to Zion. Verse 10 is for Marks alone and verse 11 for Whitney alone. Verses 12 through 15 belong to Oliver Granger, and verse 16 is addressed to everyone in Kirtland. The summary describes two verses of that, and most of the chapter is instructions and appointments.

What does verse 5 tell them to do with the property?

Start with the order of the chapter, because the instruction comes before the rebuke. Verse 1 tells William Marks and Newel K. Whitney to settle up their business speedily and leave Kirtland, with a deadline set by the weather. Verses 2 and 3 say it twice more: don't tarry, because it won't go well for them if they do.

Then verse 4, which is the verse the summary is built on.

Let them repent of all their sins, and of all their covetous desires, before me, saith the Lord; for what is property unto me? saith the Lord.

That is a call to repent of covetous desires and I'm not going to pretend otherwise. The next verse is about the property itself.

Let the properties of Kirtland be turned out for debts, saith the Lord. Let them go, saith the Lord, and whatsoever remaineth, let it remain in your hands, saith the Lord.

The verse does tell them to let the properties go, and verse 1 has already told them to leave Kirtland, so I'm not claiming the chapter goes easy on property. It also says what they go for, which is debts. Whatever remains stays in their hands. That's three things in one verse. There's a release, a purpose for it and a remainder that is theirs.

Verses 6 and 7 answer the question from verse 4 with more questions. Has the Lord not the fowls of heaven, the fish of the sea and the beasts of the mountains, and will he not make solitary places bud and blossom and bring forth in abundance? To me that reads as a promise of provision, which is a strange thing to say to a man you're only scolding.

Marks, Whitney and the size words

Verse 10 is for Marks, and it has a famous echo.

Let my servant William Marks be faithful over a few things, and he shall be a ruler over many.

Matthew 25 has "faithful over a few things, I will make thee ruler over many things" twice, in verse 21 for the servant who traded five talents and again in verse 23 for the one who traded two. The wording in D&C 117 is close but it isn't a copy. In Matthew the master says "thou hast been faithful," looking back at work finished, and the promise ends "many things." In verse 10 the faithfulness is still ahead of Marks because the sentence is a command, and the promise ends at "many." The parable also has the servant who dug a hole and hid his master's money (verses 18 and 25 through 30), and he's the one cast out. Verse 10 goes on past the promise to say Marks is to preside "in the city of Far West."

Verse 11 is for Whitney, and it's the hard one.

Let my servant Newel K. Whitney be ashamed of the Nicolaitane band and of all their secret abominations, and of all his littleness of soul before me, saith the Lord, and come up to the land of Adam-ondi-Ahman, and be a bishop unto my people, saith the Lord, not in name but in deed, saith the Lord.

I'll leave the band alone for now (there's a question on it below). What I notice is the size words. Verse 8, which comes before the verses for Marks and Whitney, has "the drop" and "the more weighty matters." Verse 10 has "a few things" for Marks, and verse 11 has "littleness of soul" for Whitney. Property doesn't come up in verse 11 at all.

D&C 72:8 names Whitney as the man who "shall be appointed and ordained unto this power," and verse 2 of that chapter says the power is a bishop's. I read verse 11's "not in name but in deed" against that, as something said to a man the Lord had already named for the office. That's my reading. Verse 11 also says "be a bishop unto my people" and sends him to Adam-ondi-Ahman, so it could as easily be a new charge, and I can't tell which from the text.

Granger, the one with the business job

Oliver Granger gets four verses to himself, 12 through 15, where Marks and Whitney get one apiece, and not one of the four is a rebuke. His name is to be had in sacred remembrance from generation to generation (verse 12). He's to contend earnestly for the redemption of the First Presidency, and then comes a line I'd put on a wall if I had a wall for it: "when he falls he shall rise again, for his sacrifice shall be more sacred unto me than his increase." Verse 14 tells him to come up hither speedily, unto the land of Zion. In due time, it says, he'll be "made a merchant unto my name, saith the Lord, for the benefit of my people." The name there is the Lord's. Verse 15 says let no man despise him.

A summary that says the chapter rebukes property has to get around two verses, one setting sacrifice above increase and the next making the same man a merchant for the people's benefit.

What Granger was actually doing that summer comes from the histories, not the chapter. The Church's biography and the history sources I read have him assigned to settle Joseph Smith's business affairs in Kirtland, and say he carried on doing that. The verse itself doesn't say "debts" or "business," and it doesn't send him back to Kirtland. It says come up to Zion. I can't make those two sit together from the text I have, so I'll leave them where they are.

Settling business is what brings Leland Yost to mind, and verse 1 says to do it speedily. He ran the dry cleaner on Main Street in Bountiful when I was a kid, and the spring I was fifteen he sold it to a man from Layton. My mother sent me in on a Saturday for my dad's shirts. Mr. Yost was at the counter with a roll of stamps and a stack of envelopes, working through the back rack, which held maybe sixty garments nobody had picked up in over a year. Each had a pink ticket pinned to it with a name and a number, and he was looking every number up in a ledger and writing to every name. He asked whether I knew a family called Dastrup, because he had a navy suit tagged with their name and a phone number that had been disconnected. I didn't. The radio on the shelf behind him was playing Perry Como loud enough that he had to say the name twice. My mother hadn't heard of them either. I heard later that the buyer had wanted the keys three weeks earlier than he got them. I never learned what the shop sold for, and I never learned what happened to the Dastrups' suit. That much care sits a little against "speedily."

What is "the drop" in verse 8?

Verse 8 is where the money reading has its best footing, so it's worth a look. Last Wednesday's post on D&C 116 quoted verse 8's opening question about "room enough" in passing, so I'll take the rest here.

Is there not room enough on the mountains of Adam-ondi-Ahman, and on the plains of Olaha Shinehah, or the land where Adam dwelt, that you should covet that which is but the drop, and neglect the more weighty matters?

Two things are named, coveting the drop and neglecting the more weighty matters, and which of them the Lord minds more isn't something the verse tells me. The neglect reads to me like the cost of the coveting, but that's an impression and not a finding. Neither "the drop" nor "the more weighty matters" is defined in the verse. Verse 16 is the third place that could pass for the summary, because it mentions overthrowing the moneychangers. But it's addressed to "all my servants in the land of Kirtland," not to the three men, it asks them to remember the Lord and "mine house also, to keep and preserve it holy," and it puts the timing of the overthrow in the Lord's hands: "in mine own due time." I don't know what to do with that verse, so I'm not hanging a lesson on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does D&C 117 say it's wrong to own property?

No, and in a couple of places it points the other way. Verse 5 has the men pay their debts and keep what's left, and verse 14 makes Granger a merchant. What the chapter warns against is covetous desires (verse 4) and neglecting the more weighty matters (verse 8). That is a different thing from owning a house in Kirtland.

Who was Oliver Granger?

The chapter gives him four verses and no biography. The Church's biography, as I read it, has him settling Church business in Kirtland and dying there in 1841. I'd leave birth dates alone, since the sources I found didn't agree.

What was the Nicolaitane band?

The verse doesn't say. The Church's footnote sends you to Revelation 2, where Christ tells Ephesus "thou hatest the deeds of the Nicolaitans" (verse 6) and tells Pergamos about those who hold "the doctrine of the Nicolaitans" (verse 15). Casey Paul Griffiths, in his commentary on the section, calls it likely a reference to apostate members who stayed behind in Kirtland. A footnote isn't an identification, and "likely" is his word.

Where is Olaha Shinehah?

Verse 8 puts those plains alongside the mountains of Adam-ondi-Ahman and "the land where Adam dwelt." Past that, nobody I read claims to know, and Griffiths says outright that the meaning of the name isn't known. One proposal links it to the sun and moon names in Abraham 3:13, where Shinehah is the sun and Olea is the moon. I'd treat that as a proposal.

On the frontage road

There was a hawk on the third light pole along the frontage road this morning, with its feathers all puffed out against the cold.

— D.

D&C 117: Nine Verses to Two Men, Then Three Separate Charges