Micah 6:8 and Mosiah 2:17 on an Ordinary Tuesday
Melissa's sister Hannah said it to me on speakerphone last Sunday afternoon. She's a nurse in Cedar City and she was partway through a run of twelve-hour shifts. "Moses gets shown every world there is," she said. "I get shown a med cart. So what does God actually want from somebody on a Tuesday? And please don't say serve."
I told her I'd look into it.
Melissa, from across the kitchen, said she'd like to hear what I found, which I took as a warning.
Sundays on this site get a topic instead of the next chapter, so here is the look. The short version is that Micah 6:8 gives the three verbs and Mosiah 2:17 says where they land. The longer version has a few things in it I didn't expect.
Does the size of Moses 1 leave any room for a Tuesday?
Moses 1 is the widest view in the standard works, and the chapter admits what that view does to a person. Moses is shown the world and all its children. Then the presence of God withdraws and he falls to the earth, where he lies for "many hours" (verse 10) and then says to himself, "man is nothing, which thing I never had supposed."
That's Moses talking, and the chapter doesn't leave him lying there on the ground where he said it. A little further down the Lord says "there is no end to my works, neither to my words" (verse 38), and in the next verse tells him what the work is: "to bring to pass the immortality and eternal life of man" (verse 39). The scale is real. What's being worked on at that scale is people, which means a person's Tuesday is not off the map.
I wrote about verse 39 itself back in April and won't go over it again. It matters here because of Hannah's contrast. She's picturing the universe on one side and a med cart on the other, and the verse puts the patients inside the work.
What are the offers in Micah 6:6-7 asking?
Start a few verses earlier than the one everybody quotes. In verse 3 the Lord says "O my people, what have I done unto thee? and wherein have I wearied thee? testify against me." Verses 4 and 5 go back through Egypt, Moses, Aaron and Miriam, Balak and Balaam. Then somebody speaks, and the text doesn't say who.
Wherewith shall I come before the Lord, and bow myself before the high God? shall I come before him with burnt offerings, with calves of a year old?
Will the Lord be pleased with thousands of rams, or with ten thousands of rivers of oil? shall I give my firstborn for my transgression, the fruit of my body for the sin of my soul?
Micah 6:6-7
Count the price as it goes up from one verse to the next. Calves a year old, then thousands of rams, then ten thousands of rivers of oil, then a child. The asker keeps bidding against himself, each offer bigger than the last, and the question underneath never changes. Will this be enough?
Nothing in these two verses says sacrifice was wrong, and I'd be careful of anyone who tells you they do. Verse 8 simply doesn't pick up any of the offers.
He hath shewed thee, O man, what is good; and what doth the Lord require of thee, but to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?
Micah 6:8
"He hath shewed thee." The answer arrives as something already told, and all three items are verbs. Not one of them is a thing you carry up to the temple. The verse doesn't rank them, and it doesn't claim to be everything God ever asks. It answers the one question that was put to it.
Where does "do justly" show up in the verses after verse 8?
Micah doesn't leave verse 8 floating. Verse 9 says the Lord's voice "crieth unto the city," and verses 10 and 11 get specific, with "the scant measure that is abominable" and "the wicked balances, and with the bag of deceitful weights." Verse 12 says the rich men are full of violence and the inhabitants have spoken lies.
So two verses after verse 8 the chapter is talking about short weight. I think that gives "do justly" a shape, though that's my reading of the neighbors, because the verse never defines the word. Read that way it's the least glamorous item on the list: a scale that reads true and a measure that isn't shaved, and whatever on your day gets weighed or counted or charted or billed or graded coming out the way it actually is.
That's about the size of a Tuesday, and you know by the end of the shift whether you did it.
What does Mosiah 2:17 add to Micah 6:8?
Benjamin's crowd came with offerings too, which is easy to forget if all you know of the speech is one verse. Mosiah 2:3 says they took "of the firstlings of their flocks, that they might offer sacrifice and burnt offerings according to the law of Moses." Those are Micah 6:6's burnt offerings, in a camp of family tents around a temple. And what Benjamin says from the tower, as it was written down, is mostly an account of how he spent his days. He never sought gold or silver from them (verse 12). He worked with his own hands so they wouldn't be "laden with taxes" (verse 14). Then comes the verse everyone knows.
And behold, I tell you these things that ye may learn wisdom; that ye may learn that when ye are in the service of your fellow beings ye are only in the service of your God.
Mosiah 2:17
The Mosiah 2 post from June went through the whole speech and spent most of its time on this verse, so I'll leave it alone. What's new when you set it beside Micah is the fit. Micah gives three verbs and the only person he names is in the third, "with thy God." He doesn't say who the justice and the mercy are done to. Benjamin does. They land on fellow beings, and what lands there counts as God's.
Hannah asked me not to say serve, and Benjamin says it, so I can't keep it out. But I think her objection is to the word with nothing in it, and Micah is what goes in it. A fair measure and some mercy for whoever is in front of you is what the service is made of on a weekday.
Then verse 18 turns it into an argument from his own case: "if I, whom ye call your king, do labor to serve you, then ought not ye to labor to serve one another?" He's the one person in that crowd who could claim an exemption, and he doesn't take it. Verse 22 has Micah's verb: "all that he requires of you is to keep his commandments." Micah asked what the Lord requires and got three infinitives, and Benjamin, answering for his own people, reaches for the same word. I'm only noting the word. Whether he has Micah in mind I don't know.
The check on all of this is verse 21. If they served God "with all your whole souls yet ye would be unprofitable servants." Verse 24 adds "ye are still indebted unto him." Set that beside Micah 6:7 and you have one person offering more and more, and another told that no amount would cover the debt anyway. Neither passage describes a bargain.
Is this the same list Jesus gave in Matthew 23?
It looks like a cousin. In Matthew 23:23 Jesus says the scribes and Pharisees "pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have omitted the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone."
That's a rebuke aimed at them, and I wouldn't turn it into a general list. But look at the last clause. He doesn't tell them to stop tithing mint. The small obligations stay and the weightier ones are what got dropped, which is close to what Micah does with the offerings in verses 6 and 7. Neither passage throws out what a person brings. Both say it isn't all there is.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Micah 6:8 say sacrifice and offerings were wrong?
No, and nothing in verses 6 and 7 calls the offers wrong either. Verse 8 answers a question about what to bring and doesn't take them up. Mosiah 2:3 and Matthew 23:23 both have offerings and tithes in the picture without a word against them.
Is Mosiah 2:17 saying service earns God's favor?
It can't be, because the same speech says otherwise. Verse 21 calls even whole-souled service "unprofitable," and verse 24 says "ye are still indebted unto him." Serving the people near you counts as service to God. That's a different claim from saying it pays him back.
Is Micah 6:8 everything God asks of us?
I wouldn't say so, since it answers one question in one chapter, and Mosiah 2:22 puts the requirement as keeping his commandments. Treat the three verbs as a true answer to what to bring and not as a complete inventory.
Which of the three should I start with?
Justly, because verses 10 and 11 give it a form you can check, a measure and a weight. Mercy and walking humbly are harder to see in yourself, and I'd trust the one you can see.
Read Micah 6:8 through verse 11 tomorrow morning before work. Then pick the one thing on your Monday that gets weighed or counted or graded, and make it come out honest.
— D.